Updated: Jan 24

Cover photo by Luke Tokaryk
I don't think there was a kid growing up that didn't have pancakes with the breakfast syrup's that they sold in the grocery store (unless you lived in Northern New England or Canada where maple trees are abundant).
Having pancakes, waffles, or French toast with syrup was a just a way of being a kid. We all had our tradition of where we would put the syrup. Some it would be on a separate plate, others poured right on top. For me, it was on the same dish but off to the side and I would dip into the syrup to get the perfect amount.
When we moved up to Massachusetts, we started going to the local wholesale club that sold real maple syrup. This became the standard in our household for years. It did get to the point where shortly after transitioning to real maple syrup, I couldn't go back to the breakfast syrup I grew up as a kid (by the way, it's called breakfast syrup because store brands contain little to no maple syrup). I even became a bit of a food snob where when we would go out to breakfast and they didn't have real maple syrup, I would eat my French toast plain vs having to go back to using the breakfast syrups.
For years using the wholesale club maple syrup, we never really tried anything else. Sure, we would go to restaurants that offered maple syrup, but we never ventured to try maple syrups from local producers, which is a shame I didn't start this earlier given we live in New England, home to some of the best maple syrups in the world.
The Rooted & Refined Living Expert Tip:
"Start with pouring a small amount of maple syrup on a spoon. Notice the rich color and viscosity of the pour. Next, lean in and inhale the aroma of being transported to a maple forest. Slowly taste the syrup, allowing it to rest on your tongue highlighting the notes the Sugarmaker intended."
Over the years, we did start to sample the small variety packs of maple syrup and came to really like the Amber flavor, in which the sap is collected in the middle of the harvest season vs. that dark and very dark, which are harvested towards the end. The darker varieties are used more for baking, but some people like it just the same for their pancakes.
As we started to learn about the variety differences, we realized our wholesale club syrup was on the dark side and when taste tested against some of the other maple syrups we started to buy, we realized Amber was our preference.
This then started us looking for maple syrups in our travels across New England, especially Vermont and New Hampshire. At any given time, we would have 2-3 bottles of maple syrup from different producers, but they all tasted the same to me. I never actually took the time to do a taste test.

This past weekend when Michael was home for Thanksgiving (yes, I am posting this long after writing it), I decided to do a taste test. We had a few bottles from various Vermont and New Hampshire based travels, plus one from Forest Mill Farm in Coventry, CT. This is owned by Kelly Barber and Brian Murray.

Brian used to be a customer of mine when I used to sell to Travelers Insurance. I stopped by his house, and he showed me around as they owned the farm for a few years now and have been doing upgrades ever since. He was nice enough to give me a small bottle which was one of the bottles we used for tasting. It was the Forest Mill maple syrup that prompted me to do the taste test as to me, it had a bit of a woodsy taste to it which I really liked. Unfortunately, they currently don't ship so you have to go to the Coventry farmers market to try it for yourself.
We also tried a few others and one that had a similar woodsy profile that Michael and I both liked was from Ben's Sugar Shack in New Hampshire. Ben's was an interesting story as he started his tapping maple trees as a kid (under 10 from what I recall from him being previewed on a local TV program). He then grew it to a point where he know runs a retail store selling a variety of products and made to order food in Tempeh, NH.
I then started to find it ironic that I didn't choose any of my maple syrup options that were from Vermont. It was then that I actually did some research to find what others said is the best around. One that struck me was Smugglers' Notch Maple Works, which is based in the Stowe, VT area. Stowe is one of our favorite places to visit and while my family is not into skiing, we just love the area. It has a great bike path with amazing views along a river and of Mount Mansfield. It also has some amazing restaurants including a cafe in a bike shop, Ranch Camp Stowe. Smugglers' Notch itself is breathtaking. It is a windy road up to the top where many cars get stuck because of the massive boulders next to the road. During the summer, it is near impossible to park in the area due to the extremely limited parking. We went last fall just after peak leaf peeping for our anniversary and had no problems parking, walking around, and hiking. It's also called Smugglers' Notch because people used to illegally transport goods like liquor and livestock in its caves and forests during the Embargo Act in the early 1800's and the Prohibition era of the 1920's. Smugglers' Notch is also home to some amazing waterfalls.
Quick side story. We went up with friends many years ago and we did a small hike to a Moss Glen Falls (a waterfall). Michael and I went up the path to a section where you could take pictures. We sat on a log and as I was taking our selfie, the phone slipped out of my hand and slid down the hill (it was very dry out for the last few weeks prior) and over the side to a 100-foot drop. After going around, I could see that it landed on a jagged area not far from the top but nowhere near safe to get it myself. I assumed it was gone for good. Then the friend I was with was a PhD in Engineering and said we can get it. I assumed he was crazy but he thought, we are in Stowe and people like to rappel down mountains for fun.
So, we went on a quest to 3 different shops (bike, fishing, and other bike shop) to find Tag, a person that was willing to do it. The next day, it took Tag about 10 minutes to rappel down over the cliff and secured my phone. I did pay him for his time, which was much cheaper than having to buy a new one.

Ok, back to the maple syrup. I just had two varieties of the Smugglers' Notch Maple Works shipped to my house to try (video unboxing and taste test at the end of the story). The first was Single Forest Wood Fired Maple Syrup and the second was the Rum Barrel Aged Maple Syrup. The things that I loved was the complex, woody taste of the syrup as it made me feel like I was back in Stowe.
The Smugglers' Notch syrups are a bit more expensive than traditional maple syrup so I plan to use it when I have something where I can really take advantage of the taste. The first thing that comes to mind is some candied walnuts (which I am getting better at making) as well as some homemade French Toast.

I think the Single Forest Wood Fired Maple Syrup is going to be one of my new favorite products and I am excited to go back to Stowe for a visit to their tasting room. The father and son owners, Ron and Jeremy Elliott, primarily own a distillery and then partnered with longtime maple producer Craig Walker of Underhill, VT. Ron and Jeremy took their maple syrup a step further to barrel age it in their own distillery barrels.
I am now a huge fan of Smugglers' Notch Maple Works. It is definitely worth the upgraded sensory experience.
Start Your Own Vermont Maple Syrup Sensory Experience
If you’re curious to start your Vermont maple syrup sensory experience, I’ve listed a few of my favorite products and one that I haven't tried yet but I am sure will be a fan favorite. Give one a try and let me know your thoughts in the comments!
For Transparency: Some of the links in this post are affiliate links. If you purchase through them, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. I only recommend products I truly love and use myself.









